Sunday, February 17, 2013

Memory, Sorrow, and Thorn - a series

I've just finished Tad Williams' trilogy (though book three is sometimes split into two books) Memory, Sorrow, and Thorn. I have to say I enjoyed it much more than I thought I would before I began. The first positive comment I'll make is that I'm at a loss for what to read now. I'm still stuck on Simon, Miriamele, and Binabik.

Plain and simple, this was good epic fantasy. It wasn't 'the best I've ever read', but it was definitely worth the many hours it took to read. I'll start with what I really liked:

The action was great! Before I started writing, I figured fight scenes would be the easiest to write. But when you think about it, you have to give words to all different types of movements, whether a person's body, a horse, or a troop, and make it believable and understandable to the reader. It's hard. Williams does very well in this trilogy.

Williams uses white space more often than most traditional fantasy writers. He has chapter breaks obviously, then section breaks divided by a symbol (meaning a shift in character/perspective), and then just regular white space line breaks. These often come when a character sleeps, is knocked unconcious, or must do a few minutes or hours of monotonous travel that Williams knew we wouldn't care to read. Not only does it work well when reading, but they are nice stopping points if you don't like to end during action or reading an entire chapter at a time.

There was a good amount of romance, including a few sex scenes that were just graphic enough to let you know what was going on, but not graphic enough to naturally fit in a romance novel. I don't know about the next guy or gal, but I like me a little lovin' to go with my swords and sorcery (whether it's 'wink wink' lovin' or feelings lovin').

The idea of magical swords being the center of the series seems like a fantasy cliche, but if you stick with it to the end, there's some nice twists.

Characters are developed nicely, especially Simon, as he is the main character.

The ending was great, appropriate amount of action, more frantic than any other parts of the series. There was also the perfect amount of time spent after the final climactic event; didn't abruptly end, and didn't include a montage of years proceeding the final climax.

Now for the very few things I had issues with:

The plot twists were great, but I felt like the first three books (if To Green Angel Tower is broken into two) laid all the ground work for the fireworks of the last book. There were still some minor detonations in the first books, but nothing like the last one (this may seem obvious, as in 'Duh, all the revelations and stuff come at the end', but I would have liked some bigger events nearer the beginning and middle).

For some reason it started off very slow for me. Later on, those first pages provide a bit of groundwork, but I almost had to push myself through those opening pages (though many people say this about The Fellowship of the Ring).

I didn't feel like places were really fleshed out. Obviously the Hayholt, the main castle, was done well, but so much time and so many conversations cover the structure it would be a shame for the reader not to understand or have a strong mental image of the place. A lot of the time characters are on the move, so attention really shouldn't be on the place, but I found myself having to really work a few times to create mental images of the environment.

In no way do I feel that these negatives should deter a reader from picking up Tad Williams' Memory, Sorrow, and Thorn trilogy. It was definitely worth the read (though just a suggestion, maybe don't read it immediately after you finish the latest A Song of Ice and Fire).

No comments:

Post a Comment