Sunday, April 28, 2013

The Wheel of Time: A Memory of Light


This is it. It's done. There will be no more in this series. Very sad, when you think about it. They just kept coming. Even after Robert Jordan died, we expected one more book, but Brandon Sanderson gave us three. Is that good, or bad? Eh, really up to you. I think there was probably so much information, as Sanderson said, that there couldn't be one final book. Anyway, here is my take on it.
Negative:
This was the fantasy series of all fantasy for me when I was growing up. I wasn't old enough to appreciate LotR like it should have been, but old enough to understand good fantasy. Robert Jordan's death sucked. I knew the series would still be completed, but I knew it wouldn't be done as well. That was true. I read 12 and 13 a while ago, but I don't remember it being too much of a downgrade from Jordan. Sanderson is, after all, an established author himself. But A Memory of Light? It's not close at all. Granted, he did say he wouldn't even try to copy Jordan's writing ability, but what I got from this most recent book was blah. Details seem to be left out so paragraphs will remain short. Characters are boiled down to their established stereotypes (that Jordan took 11 books to establish, yet managed to present characteristics in new and enlightening ways). Obvious is the way different cultures have of speaking. I've never wanted to skip over dialogue (or any writing, rather), but after reading three lines of speech from Bayle Domon, I was about ready to. It seems like there is a 'do be' in every single sentence the character utters.

Postive:

It got better. The beginning was atrocious, as the above description details, yet once Sanderson got into the detailed working of the last battle, his writing style shone through magnificently. This battle was massive. It took the whole book to describe it, so there was a lot going on. I don't want to give anything away, but how Sanderson manages every angle of the battle, including the dark side, is fantastic. The stereotypes I listed above even get better. Not way better, but better. 

No one is going to start with the last book of the series, so I know if you've started the series, you'll read the last one. While the characters seemed to lose some of their depth, the actual Last Battle was amazingly rendered. The negative portion above was gleaned from the first eighth or so of the book, but if you stick with it (and I know you will), it gets better. Maybe think about a short fantasy series next. So A Song of Ice and Fire.